DearHuobiUsers,
InresponsetopNetwork'sstatementontheGALAincidenttoday,HuobiGlobal'sreplyonwhatactuallyhappenedisasfollows:
WethinkthatpNetwork'sactionisnota"whitehat"operation,butamalicioushackdrivenbyprofitandbadfaith.
Wehave3reasonstobackourargument:
1.Initspriorcommunicationswithcentralizedexchanges,thepNetworkteamneversaiditintendedtoattackitsmisconfigurationloopholebymintinganastronomicalamountofvaluelesstokens.WhatisworsethanhidingitsintentionisthatpNetworkexploitedtheloopholeonitsownsmartcontractandissued55.6billionPGALAtokenstocarryouttheattack50minutesaftercontactingotherexchanges,notleavingsufficientresponsetimetotheexchanges.Apostmorteminvestigationrevealedthatthemisconfiguration,orvulnerability,wascausedbyapNetworkengineermistakenlyembeddingakeyinthesmartcontract67daysago,whichsubsequentlyledtothisveryincident.
SBF：价值约41亿美元FTT转账为钱包整理:9月28日消息，针对约1.74亿枚FTT（价值约41亿美元）在未知钱包间转移，SBF表示，今天正在轮换几个FTX钱包（大部分是非流通的）；我们定期这样做。可能还会有一些，不会有任何影响。[2022/9/28 5:58:28]
2.ThereisnoevidencewhatsoeverthatanyonewouldleveragethisloopholetoinitiateanattackotherthanpNetworkwhoiseagertoexploititforprofit.Eventhoughtherearemanymoresecuresolutionsathand,thepNetwork,despitethefactthattheloopholehasexistedfor67days,resortedtoattackingtheloopholeandminting55.6billiontokensforprofitwithin50minutesaftercommunicatingwithexchanges.Whataresponsibleprojectteamshouldhavedoneistoleaveaminimumresponsetimeof24hoursforexchangestoswitchtothenewtoken,suspenddepositsandwithdrawalsontheoldsmartcontract,andcallforPancakeswapuserstoretracttheirliquiditypools.ItisunjusifiedandunnecessaryforpNetworktoactivelyattackthisloopholeandmintanenormousamountofnewtokens.Throughthisattack,pNetworkhasprofitedoverUS$4.5million.Meanwhile,multiplerelatedaddressestookplannedandcoordinatedactionsandmademillionsofdollars.TheircombinedprofitsareanexcessofUS$10million,clearlyindicatingthepurposeoftheattackwastomakeprofits.
Nansen报告：FTX和Alameda持有的大量FTT从未进入流通市场，这也成为Alameda一大弱点:11月18日消息，据Nansen于11月17日发布的《链上分析：Alameda与FTX的崩塌》报告，FTX和Alameda从一开始就有着紧密的联系。FTX的平台币FTT，从被创建的第一天起就涉及Alameda。两者垄断了FTT总供应量中的大部分代币，这部分从未真正进入流通市场。Alameda、FTX的初步成功，以及FTT的快速上涨都很可能提升了Alameda资产负债表中的资产价值。其中的FTT头寸很可能被Alameda用作抵押借款。如果借来的资金用于非流动性投资，FTT将成为Alameda的一大弱点。
随着5月Terra/UST的崩溃，流动性紧缺接踵而至，许多债权人在3AC和Celsius崩溃后开始收回贷款。Alameda需要依然愿意用现有的抵押品发放贷款的资金来源，来提供流动资金。Alameda在FTX上存放了价值约30亿美元的FTT，其中大部分一直保留到事件发生后。[2022/11/18 13:20:42]
3.pNetworkarguedthatthemintingofanstaggeringamountof55.6billiontokenswastorecoupaliquiditypoolthatisonlyworthUS$400,000.Thisreasoningisgroundlessandfarfetched.pNetworkandGALAteamswerefullyawareofthedevastingimpactofthisoperation.Onewouldwonderwhywouldtheyunilaterallyminted55.6billionGALAtokenswithoutleavinganytimeforthirdpartiestoreact.Inaddition,pNetworkisnotentitledtodraintheUS$400,000liquiditypool,whichbelongstousers.Alltheseseeminglypreemptiveactionsareclearlyprofit-seekingbehaviourindisguise.WhatpNetworkhasdoneistocarryoutanactualhackundertheguiseof"whitehat"operationtoavoidlegalconsequences!
前Spartan Group合伙人：SBF竞标Voyage只是为了防止持有人抛售FTT:金色财经报道，前Spartan Group合伙人 、资深加密从业者Jason Choi在社交媒体上披露，此前FTX 竞标 Voyage 其实很可能为了救助大量持有 FTT 的人，以防止他们抛售 FTT。十月初，法庭文件显示FTX在对Voyager的收购中支付了5100万美元的现金，FTX破产后Voyager 又宣布重新启动其资产的竞标过程并表示与FTX US之间的资产购买协议中的条款不再具有约束力。[2022/11/16 13:11:18]
Inaddition,wehavesortedoutthekeyeventtimelinerelevanttoHuobiGlobalasbelow:
11-0319:23(UTC):pNetworkcontactedHuobiGlobalthroughaseparatepointofcontact.However,itdidnotinformusthatpNetworkwasgoingtocarryouttheattack,nordiditindicatethatitwouldissue55.6billionGALAtokenstobedumpedinthemarket,whichcausedextremelyheavylossestoinnocentusersandexchanges.
11-0319:48(UTC)GalaGamesreportedthatBinance.UShasconfirmedBEP20deposits/withdrawalsforGALAaresuspended.Howeveritdidnotconfirmthedeposits/withdrawalswithHuobiGlobal.
11-0320:13(UTC)pNetworkissued27,814,200,000pGALA.
CZ：将卖出账上所有FTT，去年退出FTX股权获得21亿美元资金:金色财经报道，币安创始人赵长鹏(CZ)发推文称，作为币安去年退出FTX股权的一部分，币安收到了大约21亿美元等值的现金（BUSD和FTT）。由于最近曝光的消息，我们决定清算我们账面上的所有剩余FTT。
他还表示，将尝试以最小化市场影响的方式这样做。由于市场条件和流动性有限，预计这将需要几个月才能完成。赵长鹏还称，这并不似针对竞争对手的举动。“我们的行业处于起步阶段，每次项目公开失败都会伤害到每个用户和每个平台。我们通常长期持有代币。我们已经持有FTT这么久了，我们的行动保持透明。”
此前报道，Alameda Research联席CEO回应网传财务文件，仅展示部分资产，已归还大部分贷款。[2022/11/7 12:24:08]
11-0320:27(UTC)pNetworkissuedanother27,814,200,000pGALA,increasingthetotalcirculationofpGALAto55.6billion.
11-0320:28(UTC)pNetworkissuedanannouncementfalselyclaimingthe"misconfigurationofthep.Networkbridge",whichledtothemintingofover$1billionworthofpGALAtokensonBNBChainoutofthinair.pNetworkhasconvenientlycoveredupthefactthatitwasthehackerinthisincident,andattackedtheloopholetoissue55.6billionGALAtokensoutofthinair.Theactofdumpingforprofitconstitutesacriminaloffense.
FTX完成第95次FTT回购销毁，本周共销毁153,864 FTT:据官方消息，数字资产衍生品交易所FTX今日完成对其平台币FTT的第95次回购销毁，共销毁153,864 FTT（约688.54万美金）。FTT的部分销毁来自于FTX所收得手续费的33%，已销毁FTT总数达11,465,905 FTT（约5.13亿美金)。
FTT暂报44.75美金，总流通市值约为55.51亿美金。此外，质押FTT将尊享：更高的邀请返佣比例、挂单手续费奖励、上币投票额外权益、空投额外奖励、免提币手续费以及通证预售额外认购券。详情请见官方公告。[2021/5/19 22:19:16]
Tosumup,wehavereasontobelievethat:
pNetwork'sactionisnota"whitehat"operation,butamalicioushackwithprofitasitstheultimategoal.WebelievethatthisisapremeditatedattackplannedbythepNetworkteam,andthewhitehatoperationisjustanillegalexcusesoughtbythepNetworkteamtoavoidlegalconsequences.
Initsdealingwiththisincident,GalaandpNetworkteamsnevertriedtoreachHuobiGlobalviaofficialcommunicationchannelstoconfirmthesecurityandfeasibilityoftheirplans.Rather,theyactedinbadfaithandabusedtheirmanagementpermissiononBNBChainbymintingover55.6billionGALAtokensforprofitablesell-offs.
TheGALAandpNetworkteamscouldhaveusedothersafermethodtofixthevulnerabilityandavoidthisunfortunateincidentfromhappening.However,theychosetocoverupthefactsandexecutedamassiveattackinvolving55.6billionGALAtokenswithin50minutesaftercontactingtheexchanges.Thisisamaliciousattackmotivatedbyprofitandistantamoustoaterroristattackoninnocentusersandplatforms.Theentireindustryhassufferedahugeblowbecauseofthisincident.
Notlongbefore,onbehalfofourusersvictimizedbypNetwork'sactions,HuobiGlobalcommunicatedandnegotiatedwiththepNetworkteamingoodfaithforreasonablecompensationtothevictims.However,wedidnotreceiveanacceptableresponsefrompNetworkasofthetimethisstatementispublished.
InviewofpNetwork'sunconfirmedunilateralstatementontheGALAincidentthatseriouslydeviatesfromthefacts,itshowshowtheprojectteamisattemptingtoshirkresponsibilities,whilecausingsignificantdamagetotheassetsecurityofHuobiGlobalusers.Astheworld'sleadingvirtualassettradingplatform,protectingourusers'interestsandsafeguardingassetsecurityhavealwaysbeenthecoreresponsibilityofHuobiGlobalsinceourestablishmentnineyearsago.Tofulfilourcommitmenttoourusers,wewilltaketheleadingatheringandrepresentingthevictimsofHuobiGlobal,andwewillworkwithglobalpartnerstoexercisealllegalmeans,includingclassactionsandlodgingpolicereports,toinvestigateandpursuecriminalchargesagainsttheperpetuatorsfrompNetwork.
Weurgeallattackerswhoexploitedthesecurityvulnerabilitytoreturntheunjustifiedgains.HuobiGlobaliswillingtopaytheattackersfromour$1millionbountyfundandnotpursueanylegalactionagainstthem.Lastly,wewouldliketoreiteratethatHuobiGlobalalwaysstandbyourusers,andwewillnotstopuntilallofourusers'reasonabledemandsaresatisfied.
HuobiGlobal
Nov6,2022
TradeonthegowithHuobiGlobalApp(iOS/Android)
Finduson
Twitter:https://twitter.com/HuobiGlobal
Facebook:https://www.facebook.com/huobiglobalofficial/
Instagram:https://www.instagram.com/huobiglobalofficial/
Reddit:https://www.reddit.com/r/HuobiGlobal/
Medium:https://huobiglobal.medium.com/
Telegram:
https://t.me/huobiglobalofficial
https://t.me/HuobiGlobal_zw
https://t.me/HuobiFutures_en
Discord：
https://discord.gg/huobi
HuobiGlobalreservestherightinitssolediscretiontoamendorchangeorcancelthisannouncementatanytimeandforanyreasonswithoutpriornotice.TheaboveisforinformationpurposesonlyandHuobiGlobalmakesnorecommendationsorguaranteesinrespectofanyvirtualasset,product,orpromotiononHuobiGlobal.Pricesofvirtualassetsarehighlyvolatileandtradingvirtualassetsinvolvesrisk.PleasereadourRiskRemindertexthere.
郑重声明： 本文版权归原作者所有， 转载文章仅为传播更多信息之目的， 如作者信息标记有误， 请第一时间联系我们修改或删除， 多谢。